Forever Exteriors Logo

Should You Replace Gutters or Roof First in Eau Claire, WI?

Any homeowner looking to embark on an exterior remodel understands how stressful the process can be. It’s often difficult to decide on which part of the project to take on first. This is especially true for remodeling projects that go hand in hand, such as roof and gutter replacement.

Should you replace gutters or roof first?

Forever Exteriors, one of the leading roofing companies in Eau Claire, WI, clears up the confusion in this blog post. 

Roofs and Gutters: Which Should You Replace First?

Roofs get a lot of attention during exterior remodels for good reasons. Without a fully functional roof, your home has no defense against the elements. The roof protects against snow, hail, rain, and harsh sunlight.

On the other hand, gutters serve as the foundation of your home’s drainage system. They channel melting snow and rainwater into the downspouts and away from your home’s foundation.

Since both are crucial to your home’s structural integrity, it’s understandable that you’ll want to know if you can replace one before the other.

The general rule of thumb is to replace your roof before installing a new gutter system.

Why You Should Replace Your Roof First

When replacing your roof, the roofing contractor working on the project will need to remove the gutters and install the new roofing before reattaching the gutters. If you installed a new gutter system before the replacement, the gutter will likely sustain some damage during the process.

Therefore, it’s best to hold off on installing gutters until your new roof is done. If you must replace your roofing after installing your new gutters, you’ll likely pay to repaint and repair the gutters afterward.

Ideally, you should talk to your roofing company about completing the roof and gutter installation at the same time. However, if one has to come before the other, it should be the roof first.

What Happens When You Have Significant Gutter Damage?

Have you noticed signs of gutter damage, such as leaking or pulling away from the roof? You should install a new gutter system as soon as possible.

It may not be cost-effective to install the gutters now, only to remove them down the line during a roof installation project. However, it’s the right thing to do.

Ineffective gutters expose your home to severe structural damage. The financial impact of repairing, repainting, or even installing new gutters a second time pales in comparison to the cost of dealing with foundation troubles or fixing landscaping damage.

More people are adopting an alternative approach now: installing one-piece seamless gutters. These systems do not need to be attached to the roof. Instead, technicians install them to the home’s fascia, allowing you to replace your roof without worrying about the gutters.

However, these systems are more expensive and don’t look like traditional gutter systems.

Other Factors That Should Influence Your Decision

If you’re still asking, “Should you replace gutters or roof first?” a few other factors that can help you make the right choice.

Your Roof’s Condition

Is your roof showing signs of significant damage, such as sagging or leaks? You need to prioritize roof replacement ahead of installing new gutters. If the roof is compromised, there’s only so much new gutters can do to protect your home from water damage.

Your Roof’s Age

Modern roofs are durable, but they all have a finite lifespan. If your roof has reached the end of its expected service life, you have a roof replacement project in your future. It’s best to schedule the gutter replacement at around the same time.

Inspection Recommendations

Did you get a home inspection recently in preparation for your new exterior remodel? Do you intend to schedule one soon? Wait for the inspection report to know how to tackle your remodel.

If the reports suggest replacing your roof, you can consider replacing both the roof and the gutters at once. If your roof is fine but the gutters are a concern, it makes sense to replace the gutters first.

Get Expert Advice on Your Eau Claire Exterior Remodeling Project

Should you replace gutters or roof first? Conventional wisdom says to do both at the same time, but if you only have the budget for one project, prioritize roof replacement.

Can gutter blockage cause roof leaks? It can. Therefore, you can’t ignore bad gutters for too long.

There’s no one-size-fits-all approach to any exterior remodeling project. The best way to make the right choices is to work with a professional exterior remodeling company like Forever Exteriors.

Call now to schedule a consultation.

chevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram